Science - December 2, 2017

Producing better fish feed

Tessa Louwerens

Researcher Mahmoud Haidar developed a new method to determine the energy requirements of the Nile tilapia. This will allow fish feed to be better tuned to the needs of the animals, allowing for better farming of the fish.

The tilapia is an omnivore. © Shutterstock

With fish meal and fish oil becoming increasingly scarce and less sustainable, the fish feed industry is looking at other ingredients. This also means that producers will need to recalculate the composition of the feed. ‘Proteins are the most expensive component’, Haidar explains. ‘Fish have to be fed sufficient amounts to produce fish filets. But you want to avoid the fish using surplus proteins as a source of energy. They have to get that energy from cheaper nutrients, like carbohydrates.’

Feed producers therefore mainly look at the ratio of the digestible proteins to digestible energy (DP/DE). According to Haidar, this is not very precise. ‘For some fish species, the optimal ratio isn’t known. Besides, the various ingredients, which also contain other substances, are not taken into consideration.’

Feathers difficult to digest
Haidar tested the DP/DE model on Nile tilapia, one of the most farmed fish species. The fact that it is an omnivore allows for variations in the feed composition. He discovered that young Nile tilapia in growth do not have an optimal DP/DE. No matter how much protein they are fed, they will convert everything into filets. He also noticed that fish grew better on starch than other types of carbohydrates. He then studied the influence of various ingredients that are often used in fish feed industry, such as feather meal, soy beans and rapeseed. The fish did not digest every substance equally well. ‘As the composition of feather meal isn’t similar to anything the fish would encounter in its natural habitat, it costs more energy to digest the nutrients.’

Based on these results, Haidar developed an alternative method to predict the needs of Nile tilapia. This ‘net energy model’, which is also applied in pig farming, considers not only the amount of digestible energy in the feed, but also its composition: proteins, fats, carbohydrates. By analysing the effects of various ingredients in more detail, feed can be produced that the fish can use more efficiently.

Mahmoud Haidar received his doctorate on 17 November. He carried out his research in the Aquaculture and Fisheries group, supervised by Prof. Johan Verreth and Dr Johan Schrama.

resource_wageningenur_nl_forum_reactions_wrapper for object 43 of type wm_language nl_gx_webmanager_cms_core_implementation_languageimpl 1

  • Ebe Huizinga.

    Geachte dame/heer,
    Op dit moment is tilapia uit b.v. Vietnam en China schandalig goedkoop. Waarschijnlijk door het voeren van troep.
    Mijn zoon heeft een tilapia kwekerij in Costa Rica. Hij verkoopt jongbroed want de uitgroei tot grotere maten is te duur. Het jongbroed wordt verkregen zonder gebruik te maken van hormonen en/of chemische middelen.
    We zoeken naar een voeder wat goedkoper is dan dat van Coppens en mogelijk gewoon in Costa Rica verkrijgbaar is voor een betere prijs. Concurreren met het buitenland is op dit moment onmogelijk maar toch willen we graag op een zo vis-vriendelijke en mensvriendelijke manier de vissen opkweken tot restaurant formaat. Zowel grijze als gouden kleur kunnen we produceren.
    Misschien hebben we wat aan het voorstel van Mahmoud Haidar.
    We zien graag zijn resultaten.
    Alvast hartelijk dank.
    Met vriendelijke groet,

    Ebe Huizinga.