Science - August 12, 2019

New model selects best crop varieties for each climate zone

Albert Sikkema

Statisticians at the WUR institute Biometris have developed a model that can predict the yield of many maize varieties in different climate zones quite accurately. With this tool, plant breeders can incorporate climate change in their breeding programme.


Biometris has collaborated with the French research institute INRA and other European research partners in a consortium for phenotyping of crops. Their aim was to measure the impact of environmental conditions on maize yield.

250 varieties
Biometris researcher Emilie Millet took part in the coordination of a network of 30 field trials in Europe in which 250 different maize varieties were grown under varying environmental conditions. In each field, the experimenters measured the yield, temperature, soil moisture and light intensity during the growing season.   

13 tonnes
These field trials provided a lot of data about the influence of the environment on maize yield. The German experimental station in Karlsruhe, for example, has pretty good growing conditions (20 degrees Celsius on average, regular rain) and scored an average yield of 13 tonnes of grain per hectare, while the Italian experimental station in Bologna had dry and hot weather and only produced 3 tonnes per hectare.

The researchers also grew the same maize varieties in the Montpellier Plant Phenotyping Platforms, where they could examine the impact of the weather conditions on plant development in greater detail. The Wageningen research group of Fred van Eeuwijk developed a statistical method to analyse the large amount of plant and environmental data. Moreover, they developed a model that can predict the yield of a maize variety under different environmental conditions given the variety’s DNA and its response to environmental conditions.

Millet and her colleagues tested this model by predicting the yield of 56 other maize varieties under 4 different growing conditions from another research project. The results showed that the model was quite accurate. When the corn yield was 10 tonnes per hectare, for instance, the model predicted a yield of 9 to 11 tonnes. Such an accuracy is unique, says Biometris researcher Willem Kruijer, the second author of Millet’s article in Nature Genetics.

The model also allowed ranking the maize varieties in each environment and thus predicting which varieties perform best in a given climate zone. Plant breeders can use this ranking to breed new varieties by using plant material that is best adapted to a certain climate. The model can also include simulated environmental conditions, for instance derived from IPCC-reports. This helps plant breeders to predict how the maize varieties will perform in the expected climate change, so they can anticipate the growing conditions in the future, says Millet. The model can also be useful for crops like tomatoes and potatoes, says Kruijer, provided that breeders have sufficient data of different varieties and growing conditions of these crops.

Re:actions 4

  • Germano Costa Neto

    The selection of varieties adapted to specific environmental conditions is essential for the success of any breeding program. Coupling prediction tools commonly based on the genotype-to-phenotype modeling with the novel and envirotype-to-phenotype approaches is a way to make selection platforms more accurate. Great work has been done by WUR, INRA, CIMMYT and Queensland along this path. Here at the University of São Paulo (USP, Brazil) we are also working with some of these tools. We will soon launch the EnvRtype package ( to assist breeders in this process. Bests regards!

  • Deresse Hunde

    Realy this is one of the most important model, becouse it incorporates those env'tal facters affecting the yielding potencial of agiven crops in relation to the curent climatic change and predicting the future direction of climate flactuation information, using DNA in addition to convetional methods of phenotyping of divers genotypes on d/f environments,unlike GGE focussing on phenotping and only pridicting the responsess of gentpes on the teste env't

    Threrefore it is very interesting, please sheer us lets we use and cotributes our knowlages for SSA to make it food self sufficient.

    Keep it up!!

  • Ranbir singh

    Very intersting

  • Dr Atef Nassar

    Please I need more details