Wetenschap - 14 februari 2019

Methane? Burn it!

tekst:
Roelof Kleis
2

When manure from the dairy industry is stored, it releases methane. Currently, for every litre of milk, about 13 grams of this strong greenhouse gas gets into the atmosphere. On Peter van Roessel’s farm, an unusual trial is going on to reduce these emissions.

Text Roelof Kleis, illustration Annet Scholten, photos Marije Kuiper


Series: Experimenting for the climate

The Netherlands aims to cut its greenhouse gas emissions by 49 per cent by 2030, compared with 1990. How we are going to do that is to be laid down in a comprehensive Climate Agreement. But while the politicians in The Hague haggle over the contents of that agreement, around the country numerous experiments in emission reduction are already under way. WUR is coordinating all the pilot projects for the Agriculture and Land Use sector. Resource will be taking a look at these experiments in the next four numbers. This week, episode 1: Livestock.


Farmer Peter van Roessel steps onto the enormous plastic bag behind his farmyard, accidently stepping in a puddle of water. His clogs fill up at once. But he hardly notices, as he eagerly carries on demonstrating the trial taking place on his farm.

The jovial Brabant farmer runs a dairy farm-cum-care farm in the Haarsteeg countryside near Den Bosch. What he is walking over now is a slurry bag of 52 by 26 metres, which can hold up to 1500 cubic metres of slurry. The bag is nearly full of the winter output of his 65 cows, which are in the nearby barn. It’s a strange feeling to walk over the bag, as if you were walking on a waterbed.

An Illustration of the experiment.

Biogas

The slurry bag is connected by two pipes with a much smaller gasbag beside it, which captures the gas formed in the slurry. Pure biogas, explains project leader Roland Melse, a researcher at Wageningen Livestock Research. ‘Biogas consists of 60 per cent methane and 40 per cent CO2.   The amount of methane generated depends on the temperature and the composition of the manure.’ In standard manure silos and bags, that biogas disappears into the outdoor air through ventilation pipes.

It is not easy to make good use of the methane, explains Melse. ‘The quantities from the manure storage on farms are relatively small, and they are only available for a couple of months a year. In the spring, the manure is spread on the land. The biogas is not enough to make using it to heat water economically viable.’ But you can make the methane less harmful by converting it into CO2.

That sounds a bit odd: helping the climate by producing CO2.  ‘But in fact it is climate-neutral,’ says Melse, ‘because this carbon has come from organic matter in the feed, so it is part of the short carbon cycle. By converting the methane into CO2, you convert a strong greenhouse gas into a much weaker greenhouse gas.’ One kilo of methane contributes 21 times as much to global warming than a kilo of carbon dioxide.

Burping cows

The livestock sector is a horrendous producer of methane. ‘Seventy-five per cent of the methane in the barn comes out of the animals’ mouths,’ explains Karin Groenestein of Wageningen Livestock Research. She and her colleague Ingeborg de Wolf coordinate all the climate pilots currently running in the livestock sector (see inset). ‘The manure is responsible for the other 25 per cent of the methane emissions from the barn.’ The experiments mainly target cows, as they are the major producers.

‘The average cow produces 125 kilos of methane per year in its rumen. Then there is another 40 kilos from emissions from the manure. The average pig produces about 1.5 to 2 kilos internally and 10 to 20 kilos via the manure.’

Animals are not the only methane producers, actually. Roland Melse enjoys demonstrating the sensitivity of the new methane meter that has been acquired for this project. Half of all human beings produce methane too. The apparatus, which resembles an alcohol meter, shows this accurately. Melse’s own gut flora are declared innocent. But in the case of farmer Van Roessel (and, admittedly, that of this reporter), the meter shoots up. ‘A question of genetic makeup,’ Melse reassures us. Luckily, the quantities are minute.

Farmer Peter van Roessel (left) and project leader Roland Melse of WUR inspect the material used in the methane-burning trial on Van Roessel’s farm.

Burning

The pilot is not going particularly well so far. There is very little gas formation, and none has been burned so far. The installation was set up in December, but the gas bag is still as flat as a pancake. Van Roessel and Melse think this is because of current temperatures. It is too cold for the bacteria to produce the biogas. In itself that is good news: the less methane, the better. Van Roessel: ‘But soon, when the sun shines on the manure, the gas production will get going.’

Burning the methane is one of three methods been trialled under Melse’s supervision. Besides this ‘thermic oxidation’, there are two other trials running in which the methane is oxidized biologically (by bacteria). In an above-ground variant, the gas from the manure silo is piped into a basin with a compost biofilter, where bacteria in the compost break down the methane. A soil variant provides a set of underground, perforated tubes that the gas is moved along. Soil bacteria have to do the work of breaking it down. This soil filter still has to be laid down.

The trials are carefully monitored and recorded. ‘The techniques are not new in themselves,’ says Melse. ‘What is new is that they are being demonstrated on this scale on a farm. We want to establish whether they work, how much they cost and what they deliver in the way of CO2 reduction.’


Fewer emissions in the livestock sector

The livestock sector must deliver almost one third of the reduction in emissions that the Netherlands aims to achieve by 2030. The pilots that have been planned for this – coordinated by WUR – will cost 8.5 million euros between them. That is almost half of the total of 19 million that WUR and 60 partners and subcontractors can spend on all the pilots and demo projects in the interests of the Dutch Climate Agreement.

The methane trials described in the main story come under the heading ‘reduction’: cutting emissions from manure. Other projects are about monitoring methane production in the barn, testing methane sensors and influencing methane production inside the animal, explains Karin Groenestein of Wageningen Livestock Research. ‘You can influence that methane output through the feed or the method of pasturing.’ The trials focus largely on demonstrating existing techniques on the farm.

Re:acties 2

  • Tony Herve

    I understand that the Australian Kangaroo does not produce as much methane?
    Could this be due to its gut bacteria?
    Could this bacteria be introduced into cows, sheep, goats and the like to reduce to methane gas?
    Note
    Methane is not Co2 or is it?
    Regards
    Tony Herve NDH (UK)

    Reageer
  • b

    Reageer

Reacties 3

  • A.H. Stoltenborg

    Is dit niet opnieuw een voorbeeld van een end-of-pipe oplossing? Het helpt misschien een heel klein beetje?
    Het centrale probleem is volgens mij dat door het streven naar winstmaximalisatie van o.a. banken, voedselindustrieën en verzekeraars (aangewakkerd door hun investeerders en beleggers)de boeren worden gedwongen tot opbrengstmaximalisatie. Dat leidt weer tot uitbuiting van dieren, bodem, landschappen en biodiversiteit (wereldwijd). Een race-to-the-bottum"! Zou een onderzoek naar oplossingen hiervoor niet veel meer opleveren?

  • Leo Huijsen, arts, n.p.

    Ik ben benieuwd naar de chemische reacties van de omzetting van methaan naar kooldioxide.In welke vorm komt de stikstof in het milieu?

    • Marjel Neefjes

      @ Leo Huijsen: Methaan is CH4. Dus bij verbranding komt CO2 en H2O vrij. Gelukkig geen stikstof.


Re:ageer